At Allegany Mountain Trail Saddles, our custom trail saddles are built exclusively one at a time, put together by one set of hands. Whether you are interested in a particular styling, an extra degree of comfort, or security in the saddle is your priority, we work directly with you to insure your needs are met. We take great pride in putting only top quality materials into our product. Each saddle is built with the Amish craftsmanship everyone loves, right here in the USA.

4959 REITER ROAD EAST AURORA , NY 14052

42

Verified customers have rated this business!
Return to search

Mike S.   Verified

*****
I ordered a custom Kydaho Rancher - everything in the process from first contact to delivery was absolutely stellar! The fitting process was detailed but not particularly difficult and it gave me conf

Stacy J.   Verified

*****
Melinda and Stacy are great! I love my saddle! Very comfortable and beautiful!

Bill W.   Verified

*****
Great communication, committed to exceeding expectations, fabulous workmanship, perfect fit.

Cyril B.   Verified

*****
With the help of Melinda and Stacy I now have the pleasure of going on a hike with my mare, relaxed and in good shape. Whether to define the choice of form or the options according to my request were

Marie L.   Verified

*****
I have a great experience with all the process of purchase my new saddle. The saddle fit perfectly to my Missouri foxtrotted mare that was not happy with her previous gaited saddle that was just to wi

Daniella P.   Verified

*****
I love my saddle! Stacie was very patient with trying different trees for my hard to fit gelding making sure the tree did not bridge. I then tried different saddles so we made sure my ride was comfort

Ginger M.   Verified

*****
Love my custom saddle. Great quality, great fit for my horse and for me. Beautiful workmanship and great service. It is well designed and exactly as ordered. Wish i had ordered one a long time ago.

Mary L.   Verified

*****
I have ordered 2 saddles from Stacy and she and Melinda have been great to work with. They send the forms, I take the photos and upload, they get back to me right away. Each saddle fits the horse pe

Bethany H.   Verified

*****
I have a very hard to fit horse with a big shoulder and short back. The ladies of AMTS did a fabulous job of making her comfortable! They stayed patient with me and all my questions. I absolutely love

Diane H.   Verified

*****
Last summer I ordered an Allegany saddle. I am 70 years old and needed a trail saddle that was light as well as safe. They worked with me and I ended up with a lovely trail saddle and i no longer ha

Colleen S.   Verified

*****
Amazing customer service and top notch quality!!!!!!!

Robynne C.   Verified

*****
I've purchased two AMTS saddles, and I'm thrilled with the quality and fit! I'll never purchase from a different saddlemaker. Staci is a joy to work with. She's extremely knowledgeable about t

Jack B.   Verified

*****
I ordered my custom saddle from Allegany Saddles this year 2017. Having never purchased let alone ordered one for my horse I had just purchased, this was going to be daunting. Well, what transpired w

Colette S.   Verified

*****
Great communication. Expertise was superb, they can fit saddles. Highly recommended.

Jean A.   Verified

*****
I have now order two custom saddles from Allegany. I am thrilled with both. My horses gait more easily and I feel comfortable and secure. Stacy and Melinda made the process easy and were quite pati

Becky S.   Verified

*****
The folks at Allegany Saddles helped me through the process and made recommendations based on their experience and expertise that was spot on. I've received a beautiful, quality saddle that fits both

Eric U.   Verified

*****
Working with Allegany to get our saddles made was a wonder experience. They provided assistance when needed. The saddles fit perfectly and are extremely comfortable. I would recommend them to anyon

PJ R.   Verified

*****
I will post a letter of appreciation to Staci and Melinda on their website. These ladies are A++. They are professional and absolutely know their saddle building art. Staci and Melinda (and their ar

Kelly T.   Verified

*****
Nice saddle. Only issue was tree was late because of Christmas holiday. Good value, high quality

Sue D.   Verified

*****
The folks at Allegany Saddles really went the extra mile in seeking the perfect fit for my big QH mare. Their process of sending tree forms and requesting photos is very reassuring, because I could s

Jennifer R.   Verified

*****
The entire experience was wonderful and easy! I highly recommend this company and the saddles! Beautiful craftsmanship and good quality materials. Fits me and my horse perfectly. Would totally order f

Lindsay Y.   Verified

*****
great people and very helpful and knowledgeable

Maureen O.   Verified

*****
Hard to fit 16.3 hands, off track Standardbred. Had a few saddle fitters try to make a comfortable saddle for me and my horse but they failed. Allegany Saddles came out, took their time and measured t

Joanne C.   Verified

*****
They make a gorgeous saddle, to your specifications. The fitting process to ensure comfort for your horse takes a few days of photos and videos, with a result that fits your horse to a "T"! The "fun

Elizabeth S.   Verified

*****
Stacy worked REALLY hard to fit my horse to the correct form and tree. He is a truly hard horse to have a saddle be on him without rocking or sliding. After many pictures and videos sent, she was ab

Helge B.   Verified

*****
The best attention to detail and dedication to customer satisfaction that I have seen from any saddle company. Their saddles fit the horse and make the rider feel both comfortable and secure. I recom

Sharon K.   Verified

*****
I am a repeat customer with Allegany Saddles who is extremely satisfied. The main consideration for me was fitting my horse. I had purchased a "custom fitted" saddle from another company with terrible

Elizabeth H.   Verified

*****
I love the custom western trail saddle that I ordered for my broad, short backed Gypsy Vanner mare. I also ordered saddle bags and a matching headstall. Everything is top quality, gorgeous and the sad

Lauren D.   Verified

*****
How many ways can I say "I love my saddles"!!! I have 2 saddles and will be ordering a 3rd very soon. The fit of the saddle for my horses is spot on, it has made such a difference on our long trail

Jennifer B.   Verified

*****
Excellent customer service and excellent saddles! If I ever need another saddle I will buy from Allegany again!

Trina F.   Verified

*****
We have just gotten our 3rd saddle from them! Very pleased with product and process ! Well worth the small wait to truly have a saddle that really fits your horse ! Totally satisfied don't change a th

Jessie S.   Verified

*****
Exceptional experience, hands down. I wouldn't and will not ride in any other saddle ever again! AMTS is extremely knowledgeable about horses and their saddle fit. My horse is happier and moves freely

Kim Y.   Verified

*****
My husband and I both ordered saddles, I ride a Rocky Mountain Horse and he rides a Gaited Mule. So as you can imagine we both needed different saddles. Allegany worked closely with us to make sure we

Bailey N.   Verified

*****
Extremely happy throughout the entire process. Easy and fast way to order an amazing custom saddle for you and your horses/mules with the utmost quality and detail. Will be a returning customer A+++

Angela R.   Verified

*****
I had a very good experience. Ordering was easy and I love the product. It took longer to receive than I had anticipated but it was to make the product perfect, so it was worth the wait. I LOVE my

Kathryn M.   Verified

*****
Top notch business. You want custom, this is the saddle company to get it done. I love my Allegany Saddle! Can't say enough about customer service. Kathryn from Kamloops BC Canada.

Bob B.   Verified

*****
I couldn't have asked for a better experience and a better product. I like my saddle more every time I ride in it. The quality is easily equal to saddles costing at least $1,000 more.

Kecia M.   Verified

*****
The overall experience was amazing to say the least! Will continue to recommend them to anyone I find out on the trail. Thank you for such quality and fantastic customer service!

Karen G.   Verified

*****
The saddle is beautiful. High quality one of a kind. Would highly recommend to anyone.

Patricia M.   Verified

*****
I highly recommend Allegany Mountain Trail Saddles. Exceptional service and quality; superior comfort for the horse and human. As a retired horse trainer that has ridden in many saddles, treed and t

Cathy H.   Verified

*****
I had problems trying to fit my Saddlebred cross QH with a good fitting saddle. I discovered Allegany from Helge a trainer here in Ohio. Not only did I receive a perfect fit for my horse Red, but th

Roxanne M.   Verified

*****
AMTS company makes every possible effort to create the very best fitting saddle for you and your horse. Each and every saddle is a unique, functional piece of art work. AMTS will assist in designing
  • ***** 5
  • ***** 5
  • ***** 4.9
  • ***** 5
  • ***** 5
  • ***** 5