Top Rated Local

Claimed

Allegany Saddles

Favorite Added Favorite Removed
96.00  Rating Score™
Other

Of 68 ratings posted on 2 verified review sites, Allegany Saddles has an average rating of 5.00 stars. This earns a Rating Score™ of 96.00.

At Allegany Mountain Trail Saddles, our custom trail saddles are built exclusively one at a time, put together by one set of hands. Whether you are interested in a particular styling, an extra degree of comfort, or security in the saddle is your priority, we work directly with you to insure your needs are met. We take great pride in putting only top quality materials into our product. Each saddle is built with the Amish craftsmanship everyone loves, right here in the USA.

Serving: EAST AURORA, NY

RateRate WebsiteWebsite CallCall Now Directions Location
5
49
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
0
49 Total Reviews
5.0
topratedlocal.com
49 reviews | 5 average
google.com
19 reviews | 5 average
*All trademarks are the property of their respective owners. See Supported Sources | Report Incorrect Source

49 ratings & reviews posted directly on Top Rated Local®

Quality
5.0
Value
5.0
Timeliness
4.9
Experience
5.0
Satisfaction
5.0
OVERALL
5.0
Showing 1-10 of 49 items.

1 review

My new saddle is beautiful. It fits my horse and it fits me. I also found the price to be an excellent value. The staff is very helpful and competent. 5 Stars!

1 review

I can’t say enough about the quality and craftsmanship of Allegany Saddles and the customer service. Staci and Melinda are a pleasure to work with. They will guide you every step of the way to make sure you have the saddle of your dreams. They won’t leave you “hanging in the balance”. They are very knowledgeable and truly care about their customers. You can rest assured you are in good hands with this company. The saddles are made with close attention to detail, they are beautiful in design and offer many optional and additional features to suit your taste and functional needs. I have a difficult to fit horse and it’s been a long road finding a saddle that was a comfortable good fit for us both. Staci and Melinda made sure they met my expectations, always listening to my needs and concerns. I commend Allegany saddles for their professionalism and creating saddles worth every penny! Thank you Allegany!

1 review

I had offered my Andalusian 3 different well made saddles. He refused them all with head bobbing, kicking his belly, objecting to cinch being tightened, refusing to go forward, groaning loudly, and trembling at the mounting block. Once I submitted my order arrangements were made for the saddle fit forms to be sent. After review of photos and videos an AW tree was recommended. There were so many options I'm sure I tested their patience but I finally chose the Kydaho Rancher. I also sent pictures of some vintage style tapaderos I liked. They were faithfully recreated. My saddle was made very timely, about 9-10 weeks, so I didn't miss a lot of riding. After a couple of weeks using my new saddle my horse's avoidance and fear behaviors went away. I tried the saddle on my Kiger Mustang just because I still had it in the barn. His occasional head bobbing and peculiar neck arching behavior under saddle disappeared and it wasn't even made for him. My horses are much happier! I am happy too because the seat is so deep and secure and I feel very close to my horse. This is good because I'm of an age where falling off is a bad idea. Did I mention it's pretty? And easy to put up on my 16 hand horse? It's black with a touch of silver studs. I call it my Hi Ho Silver saddle because my gray Andalusian looks so much like the Lone Ranger's Silver while wearing it . I strongly recommend Allegany Mountain Trail Saddles.

1 review

I purchased my first custom made wade tree saddle from Allegany trail saddles and I am very pleased with it. Staci and Melinda were so nice and pleasant and they really aimed to please me. They were very patient and i received my saddle in a very timely manner. I am so pleased and impressed with the final product and I am very impressed with the quality and craftsmanship. It is a true piece of art and I highly recommend these fine people to anyone looking for a great custom saddle at a reasonable price!

1 review

I LOVE MY SADDLE! STACI AND MELINDA WERE SO EASY TO WORK WITH. THE WORKMANSHIP AND CUSTOM ADDS ARE JUST WONDERFUL. I AM VERY SHORT AND THEY WERE ABLE TO HELP WITH THAT AND MY HORSE IS VERY BIG! LOVE IT.

1 review

OUTSTANDING! Rarely do I have the pleasure of giving, across the board, a 5 Star rating!! I truly thought after three previous custom saddles I would never find a fit that would work for my VERY short backed TWH and I am not a small woman however after another gaited rider highly recommended Allegany I was hopeful but because my previous experiences I was apprehensive. Melinda and Staci knocked it out of the park! Staci spent a lot time with a lot of patience to ensure an exact fit and I couldn't be happier! This is the first saddle, probably in my horses life (wo exaggeration) that actually fits and fits us both. Melinda's assistance in design was awesome. It's jaw dropping gorgeous, the detail and quality is beyond beautiful. I cannot thank Allegany enough for the miles and miles of happy trails ahead!!

1 review

Staci, an experienced equestrian herself, does everything in her power to make sure that each Allegany Mountain Trail Saddle truly fits the horse. Having so many saddle forms (trees) to choose from and being able to request additional design enhancements makes a huge difference in creating a correctly fitting saddle for your horse. My gaited horse has big shoulders and a very short back. His new saddle fits him perfectly and is completely comfortable for me too! The craftsmanship in the saddle from tree to finished product is excellent especially for the price. Turn around time to have a saddle made is quite reasonable. Staci and Melinda are very responsive and patient - good customer service.

1 review

Verified
I ordered a custom Kydaho Rancher - everything in the process from first contact to delivery was absolutely stellar! The fitting process was detailed but not particularly difficult and it gave me confidence from the very beginning that my new saddle would fit my horse.

1 review

Verified
Great communication, committed to exceeding expectations, fabulous workmanship, perfect fit.

1 review

Verified
Melinda and Stacy are great! I love my saddle! Very comfortable and beautiful!