Indiana’s Top Rated Local® Catering Companies Award Winner: Just Rennie’s Catering

Top Rated Local® is pleased to announce that Just Rennie’s Catering is a 2019 award winner for catering companies in Indiana!

Make your next event stand out by relying on the experts at Just Rennie’s Catering in Evansville.

Just Rennie’s Catering has received hundreds of reviews on seven verified sites with an average rating of 4.72 stars, earning them a tremendous Rating Score™ of 97.18 and a 2019 Top Rated Local award for ranking among the top five catering companies in all of Indiana!

Here’s just one of their many five-star reviews:

“We use Just Rennie’s Catering for our personal events at Y Factor Studio and for the galas and events we plan. Doug takes much pride in preparing each dish and plans each detail so well. He listens to all of our unique requests and executes the most amazing experience. Trust me, he and his team take all the stress out of having amazing food and drinks for your special night!” – Jennifer S.

A One-of-a-Kind Catering Company’s Secret to a Strong Online Reputation

Just Rennie’s Catering has managed to build the kind of reputation any business owner would envy, and to learn a little more about that reputation and this one-of-a-kind business, we sat down with Doug, who co-owns Just Rennie’s with Marla — who is also the Chef.

The first thing we wanted to know was what makes Just Rennie’s Catering unique compared to the many other catering companies in Indiana. Doug told us that what sets them apart is honesty and integrity, and went on to say:

“I’m always upfront and honest with my customers. I never oversell something to someone, and I try to give people the exact amount. I also see and keep track of what people eat and recommend the things that don’t get left over. We are professional, clean and courteous. When we go into someone’s home, we leave it better than when we found it. Everyone looks professional and well put together because of our high standards. We work hard and make everything from scratch. It takes longer but it’s better quality.”

When we asked what the secret is to such a solid online reputation at Just Rennie’s Catering, Doug pointed to the fact that they focus on providing quality service and food for their customers, and said that they don’t ask for reviews.

Making the World a Better Place by Providing a Quality Product at a Fair Price

We also wanted to know what their mission is at Just Rennie’s Catering and how they work to make the world a better place. Doug shared with us that their philosophy is to provide everyone with a good quality product at a fair price. Doug and his team are dedicated to treating everyone how they would want to be treated, and in the rare instance that they make a mistake, they always own up to it and take care of it.

Doug went on to tell us that they give back to contributing to charities, including the Red Cross, the Boys and Girls Club and more.

Outside of building a powerful online reputation, Just Rennie’s Catering has grown through magazine ads, Facebook and Instagram. They also have an online ordering form that makes it easy for people to order cookies online and have them shipped at a flat rate.

It’s clear that Doug knows a thing or two about growing a business and building an online reputation. Here’s his expert advice for the many other business owners out there:

“Start slow, and start small. Don’t rush into anything, and grow a little bit at a time. Have good connections with the right people in town. Grow your network.”


Congratulations to the team at Just Rennie’s Catering for being a 2019 Top Rated Local award winner!

We highly recommend Just Rennie’s Catering in Evansville. Visit their website today!

Share this article!